The essential difference between the two options
- High-chromium cast iron liner: integrally cast, high hardness (typically 58-65 HRC) with high carbide content and strong abrasive resistance; but limited toughness and impact capability, plus the risk of casting defects (porosity, inclusions), especially in thick sections.
- Overlay composite plate: high-chromium carbide layer metallurgically bonded to a low-carbon steel base — weldable, field-repairable, locally thickenable and essentially free of casting defects, with lower weight and usually lower cost.
Select by position, not by machine
A single crusher contains two fundamentally different failure zones: the chamber and feed zone sees continuous abrasion → overlay composite plate (thicken where wear is deepest, best value); the discharge lip and impact zone sees chipping from large lumps → high-chromium iron or impact-resistant wear steel (toughness first). Using one material across the whole machine tends to mean spending premium money where it is unnecessary and fitting the wrong material where failure is most expensive.
Particle size is the decisive input
Failure mode is set by maximum feed size, not hardness alone. Large, angular material is impact-dominated and demands toughness; fine, highly abrasive material is abrasion-dominated and demands high hardness and carbide content. Get the actual maximum particle size and the full size distribution from site measurement — many selection errors come from treating the design feed size as the actual passing size.
How the economics work
Compare unit price × service life, not unit price alone. Overlay plate is usually cheaper per piece than high-chromium iron yet often lasts longer, so the total cost favours it; and because it is field-repairable, a worn section can be rebuilt rather than the whole liner replaced. For mines with narrow shutdown windows, repairability has value that a unit-price model cannot capture.
Checks you can run on site
- Sampling for hardness and carbide inspection: compare worn and unworn areas to detect localised softening.
- Fractography: determine whether failure was brittle cleavage (carbide signature) or fatigue/impact-driven toughness failure.
- Wear depth mapping: plot the wear profile, then decide where to add thickness.
Enquiry and sampling
Send us the duty (material type, particle size, operating temperature), liner dimensions, quantity and required delivery date in one message, and you will receive a comparable quote, a sampling plan and a selection recommendation.
Key parameters at a glance
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Standard size (mm) | 1400×3400 / 1500×3000 / 2000×3000 |
| Process | Submerged Arc Welding (SAW) |
| Type | Flux-cored wire (FCAW/SAW) |